© 2026 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. The buy-side is not happy with the coking coal benchmark. Recent articles raise issues which are not isolated, but emblematic of buyer complaints across Asia and Europe, and echoed by different, though similar, grievances in the Atlantic markets. In this piece, we argue that dissatisfaction stems less from index methodology than from structural changes to coal trade flows, spot market participation, and index architecture. The solution is not increased intervention, but broader benchmark participation and the development of additional liquid reference prices coking coal (PHCC) index for both physical and financial markets. As we have argued, this benchmark never really matured. Futures volumes did not take off in the way iron ore’s did, and have never exceeded a tenth of Australia’s annual coking coal export tonnage. Physical spot liquidity has been a persistent issue with buyers and most sellers locking in as many tonnes as possible behind long-term contracts, and structural reporting of spot deals did not widely take root among producers. To complicate matters further, multiple parallel assessments for metallurgical coal in the Atlantic trade exist with less liquidity underpinning them. Often these ended up pricing against indexes from the opposite side of the world and the peak of the quality spectrum. The existing system may not have been a perfect fit for top-charging ovens, but as stamp-charging rates have risen The substance of most critiques of coking coal pricing, and commodity pricing more broadly, revolves around liquidity. Critics argue that limited spot participation creates price “stickiness” at elevated levels and disconnects assessments from steelmaking fundamentals. Some have suggested incorporating inventory levels or broader supply-demand analysis into benchmark methodologies to address this. While liquidity is variable, we believe the central challenge is not the absence of fundamental analysis in assessments, but a market structure that has evolved beyond the benchmark architecture that was built for it. Changes in trade flows, technology and index linkage matter more than adding non-price data to spot assessments. Immature market evolution Today’s coking coal mechanism followed the development of spot-based pricing in iron ore from 2010. Following a tussle between CFR China and FOB Australia references, the market settled on TSI’s FOB Australia premium hard Insight Paper | September 2026 Improving metallurgical coal market price formation Pellet Lump Concentrate 58% Fines Fines 65% 62% 61% 58% Leading Supplier Key Supplier Key Buyers • Iron ore index eligibility is determined by specification, origin irrespective. • Differences exist between origins (in gangue elements), but the product, rather than source is the determining factor. • Multliple benchmark indices (centre) co-exist. • Where one fails to find spot market support, it hitches to another (i.e. 58%). • Other products then hitch to indices that provide a ‘best fit’ as the basis of indexation. • The reference incoterm is linked to the buy-side, not the sell-side. Iron ore’s set up is deeper, more ‘nuanced’ Insight Paper | Improving metallurgical coal market price formation 2 September 2026 © 2026 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. globally (changing buying patterns), it cannot offer two camps with different needs a single satisfactory solution. Comparison with iron ore Compare this to iron ore, a useful parallel in the ferrous space. The iron ore market supports a range of fines indices on a CFR China basis. Indices with thin liquidity, such as the 58pc Fe index, are rejected in favour of more liquid ones. The 61pc fines index pulls in similar products from multiple suppliers and supply basins in a liquid, highly contested spot market which is supported by liquid futures, allowing the use of index-linked spot deals to supplement outright spot trades in price formation. Contrast the set-up in met coal. Firstly, the FOB Australia basis means all other supply locations have to reference the Australia loading price. For the US, Canada and Russia, that’s a lot of skew toward a location that is becoming less supply dominant. FOB benchmarks primarily reflect the value of material at the point of export. Import benchmarks, such as those use in iron ore, measure the value established through competition among multiple suppliers and buyers. Secondly, the ‘non premium’ met coal indices are not as well supported as those in iron ore, meaning they remain less used, creating a considerable pull towards the premium index. If the iron ore market replicated the current met coal set up, the sector would be pricing against a FOB Brazil 65pc index. Changing technology Met coal is not a pure commodity, it has five differing grade categories and its use has always been as much of an art as it is a science. But it is seeing growing user experimentation, typified by the emerging steelmaking superpower, India, where the widespread use of stamp charge coke ovens is upending traditional inter-brand relativities and value-in-use. The current benchmark was built around traditional gravity-fed ovens in mature steelmaking counties, which required a higher share of tier one coal. As the typical cokemaking mix changes and a growing share of new capacity adopts stamp charge technology, premium hard coals will make up a smaller share of total usage, substituted by hard, semisoft and non-coking coals. Shift to HCC When an entire universe of coals is tied to the PHCC index, an impact on this number ripples through a range of term-linked locations and grades via discounts. Any specific pain in that index and geography becomes more widely transmitted to other grades. This linkage is seeing it draw increasing attention and criticism, only some of which is fair. As the seaborne market splits, the top charging camp is highly vested in improving price formation for PHCC – with clear ways to do so (widen miner spot participation, increase buyer spot allocation). Even after such action, the Premium index can never be all things to everyone, everywhere. The supply and demand dynamics of one grade of coking coal from one location cannot reflect those for all others. That is not to say it cannot be improved (Argus has launched a new premium index, widening the scope of sources beyond Australia, for example). But by itself, that won’t address growing problems, so what is the solution? The market would benefit from indices serving stamp chargers. There has been lots of talk of a second-tier index. Argus has been producing a daily FOB Australian hard coking coal index since 2014. That’s a long, rich data history. Is it the right fit for a new benchmark or another financial instrument? Likely not. If one accepts the premise that one index is being asked to do far too much, when looking at solutions, 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 annualised Australia US Canada Mozambique Russia Indonesia Others — IEEFA, India Ministry of Commerce and Industry India coking coal imports mn t 0 20 40 60 80 100 Top charging indicative blend Stamp charging indicative blend PHCC US Low Vol US HVA HCC Semi-soft Non-Coking PLV preference PMV preference Feedstock demand: Top vs stamp charging % Insight Paper | Improving metallurgical coal market price formation 3 September 2026 © 2026 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. it is impossible to avoid the geographic ‘skew’ point also made around FOB Australia. Buyers everywhere are diversifying supply. That does not make Australia any less crucial as a source. It simply means it is less of a supply monolith than it was twenty five years ago. Logistics performance, weather disruptions, regulatory settings and producer cost pressures can all influence FOB values. Import benchmarks are not immune from distortions either, but by aggregating competing supply sources they are less exposed to developments in any single producing region. If concentration is already a complaint in the premium segment, where Australia is clearly the dominant supplier, it is challenging to make the argument for a FOB instrument for ‘tier 2’ hard coking coal (HCC). You can visually see the argument for an FOB basis for PHCC on the chart above. In the hard segment, there is no such overmatch. The argument is harder to make when the buyers are shifting their sourcing. The ‘top table’ of buyers is shifting, with Indian demand overtaking Japan, Korea and Taiwan combined. Moreover buyer technology is changing. Globally, gravity-fed coke batteries remain a majority, but Asia, the top steel pouring region has been a keen adopter of stamp-charging, making fluidity less of an issue in China and India and increasingly in Southeast Asia, too. Argus sees India as the clear reference point for hard coking coal imports. It avoids an unnecessary loading point anchor and would provide more optionality to products in the wider sector, too. More importantly, India is increasingly the location where Australian, North American and other hard coking coals compete directly for demand. It is where buyers compare value-in-use, optimise blends and determine relative value across origins. In HCC, that role is becoming as important for price discovery as Australia’s role is for supply. We would argue this reference offers better price formation for long-term contracts from Australian and Atlantic sources than disparate indices at a time when buyer preferences are shifting to reflect tight margins and technology is changing demand patterns. If it were to become the basis of a financial instrument, an added benefit would be the reinvigoration of futures usage - which has become moribund – both for the new and existing contracts. Such is a prerequisite to enable the consideration of ‘floating trades’ in PHCC price formation, as is the case in iron ore. It is no magic wand, however. For clearer price formation relative to price coals, it also needs a commitment from 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Australia US Canada Mozambique Prime coking coal exports mn t/yr 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Australia Canada US Russia Low-vol HCC Mid and high-vol Hard coking coal exports mn t/yr ‘Premium’ blue-water supply is overwhelmingly Australian. Exclusive FOB Aus basis for ‘Hard’ is challenging to make. 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 CSR PHCC HCC SHCC SSCC volatile matter Gravity intended blend Blend box target shifts from historic norms 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 CSR PHCC HCC SHCC SSCC volatile matter Stamp intended blend Insight Paper | Improving metallurgical coal market price formation 4 This document has been prepared by the Argus Media group (referred to herein as “Argus”) for informational purposes only and has not been prepared for any particular purpose. The information or opinions contained in this document are provided on an “as is” basis and should not be construed as legal, tax, accounting or investment advice or the rendering of legal, consulting, or other professional services of any kind. To the maximum extent permitted by law, neither Argus nor its directors, shareholders, personnel or advisers makes any representations or warranties as to the accuracy or complete- ness of this document. Argus offers no implied warranty, representation or confirmation of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose and accepts no responsibility what - soever for any damages arising from the use of or reliance on the information contained in or omitted from this document and any related materials (such as slides, handouts, other presentation documents and recordings and any other materials or information distributed at a presentation at which this document is displayed or in connection with this document) (whether arising by breach of contract, tort (including the tort of negligence), breach of statutory duty, or otherwise). No rights or remedies are conferred upon the recipients of this document or any other person. Data and information contained in the document come from a variety of sources, some of which are third parties outside Argus’ control and some of which may not have been verified. Any analysis and opinions, data, projections and forecasts provided may be based on assumptions that are not correct or which change, being dependent upon fundamentals and other factors and events subject to change and uncertainty; future results or values could be materially different from any forecast or estimates described in the document. Copyright notice: Copyright © 2026 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. All intellectual property rights in this document and the information herein are the exclusive property of Argus and/or its licensors and may only be used under licence from Argus. Without limiting the foregoing, you will not copy or reproduce any part of its contents (including, but not limited to, single prices or any other individual items of data) in any form or for any purpose whatsoever without the prior written consent of Argus. Trademark notice: ARGUS, the ARGUS logo, Argus publication titles, the tagline “illuminating the markets®”, and Argus index names are trademarks of Argus Media Limited. For addi- tional information, including details of our other trademarks, visit argusmedia.com/trademarks. argusmedia.com buyers to testing spot tonnage. What would really set it apart from the premium market is a widespread seller commitment to report trades systematically. Approached together, that could offer more than the unsuccessful fifteen-year push to price everything off PHCC from Australia. So, the challenge facing the industry is not that the premium benchmark is broken. It is that the market has evolved beyond a structure where one premium product from one exporting region is expected to price every tonne of metallurgical coal everywhere. Better-supported benchmarks further down the quality spectrum and closer to the centre of demand can create a pricing ecosystem that more closely reflects how metallurgical coal is actually traded today. Call to action Stamp charging may be changing the way global steelmaking uses Australian products, but it has not changed the structural dependence on it. At a significant slice of total seaborne supply and infrastructural and with mining bottlenecks preventing expansion among other blue-water loading locations, the stamp and top-charging communities need more options around which to structure their needs. To be clear, the gravity-fed Premium Hard led pricing complex is not going anywhere. It is simply joined at scale by a set of users with different needs. A zero-sum game this is not. A well-functioning stamp ecosystem can actually enhance the function of the existing gravity system, both physical and financial. That would enhance stability of supply for the global steelmaking industry. The alternative is for the ex-Australia industry to continue with opaque pricing, complaining about an awkward mechanism, declaiming the unfairness of ‘eating’ an Australian freight rate, seeing destructive boom-bust cycles in supply and occasionally revisiting the notion of a return to annual benchmarks. In the meanwhile and specifically for the top-charging community, one immediate action buyers can take to dilute pricing risk on long-term supply is to adopt ‘basket’ pricing on long-term contracts. This is already standard fare in iron ore markets in China and increasingly rest-of-world. It is also standard in a large volume of Australian PHCC contracts. You need only ask. Get access to Argus data here. For more information please contact: Tim Hard , SVP, Energy Transition, Business Development, Singapore tim.hard@argusmedia.com Oscar Tarneberg , VP, Metals, Business Development, London oscar.tarneberg@argusmedia.com