CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER General Offense Information Operational status: CLOSED - Complaint Issued Reported on: Jul-11-2019 (Thu.) 836 Occurred between: Jul-11-2019 (Thu.) 800 and Jul-11-2019 (Thu.) 836 Approved on: Jul-11-2019 (Thu.) by: 3039 - JON LABERGE #L25 Report submitted by: 9586 - IRWIN WIERZBICKI #709 Org unit: Patrol Team 9 Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Felony/Misdemeanor: FELONY Situation code: Single Victim/Single Offender Gang involvement: No Family violence: Yes Offenses (Completed/Attempted) Offense: # 1 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER - COMPLETED Location: Residence/Home Offender suspected of using: Not Applicable Criminal activity: None/Unknown Weapon type: Handgun Bias: None (No Bias) Related Event(s) AB CH2021-1332 AB CH2021-1333 Related Person(s) 1. Victim # 1 - VALLOW, CHARLES (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: HOUSTON , Texas 77094 Phone Numbers Business: Particulars Master Name Index Reference Name: VALLOW, CHARLES Sex: Male Race: White For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 1 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Date of birth: Address: Municipality: HOUSTON , Texas 77094 Phone numbers Business: Linkage factors Age range : 50-64 Years Aggravated assault/homicide : Argument Victim of : 0999- 0 1ST DEGREE MURDER - COMPLETED Victim's Relationship to Offender : Victim Was Spouse Person's role : Arrestee #1 Person's name : VALLOW, LORI, N Victim's Relationship to Offender : Victim Was Stranger Person's role : Arrestee #2 Person's name : DAYBELL, CHAD, G Victim's Relationship to Offender : Victim Was Other Family Member Person's role : Suspect #1 Person's name : COX, ALEXANDER, L 2. Suspect # 1 - COX, ALEXANDER L (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: SAN TAN VALLEY , Arizona 85140 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Occupation: UNKNOWN Ethnicity: White Height: 6'01 Weight: 210 lbs. Eye color: GREEN Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: COX, ALEXANDER L Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 2 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Municipality: SAN TAN VALLEY , Arizona 85140 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 50-64 Years Access to firearm : No 3. Arrestee # 1 - VALLOW, LORI N (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Height: 5'06 Weight: 125 lbs. Eye color: BLUE Facial hair color: Blonde or Strawberry Master Name Index Reference Name: VALLOW, LORI NORENE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years Armed with : Unarmed Offense: 0999- 0 1ST DEGREE MURDER - COMPLETED Arrest date: Mar-10-2021 (Wed.) Arrest type: Warrant or Submitted Case 4. Arrestee # 2 - DAYBELL, CHAD GUY (Case Specific Information) For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 3 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: 202 N 1900 E Municipality: REXBURG , Idaho 83440 Particulars Master Name Index Reference Name: DAYBELL, CHAD GUY Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: 202 N 1900 E Municipality: REXBURG , Idaho 83440 Linkage factors Age range : 50-64 Years Armed with : Unarmed Offense: 0999- 0 1ST DEGREE MURDER - COMPLETED Arrest date: Mar-10-2021 (Wed.) Arrest type: Warrant or Submitted Case 5. Witness # 3 - , ZULEMA (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: GILBERT , Arizona 85296 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Height: 5'02 Eye color: BROWN Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: , ZULEMA Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: GILBERT , Arizona 85296 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 4 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Age range : 50-64 Years 6. Witness # 4 - , MELANIE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 16 Grid: J21 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Height: 5'07 Eye color: BLUE Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: , MELANIE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 16 Grid: J21 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Age range : 30-49 Years 7. Contact # 1 - , (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: LAKESIDE , Arizona 85929 Phone Numbers Business: Cellular: Particulars Occupation: FIRE CAPTAIN Employer: CITY OF CHANDLER FD STATION #11 Height: 6'00 Weight: 220 lbs. For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 5 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Eye color: BLUE Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85286 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: Q21 Phone numbers Business: Cellular: Home: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 50-64 Years 8. Contact # 2 - (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: MESA , Arizona 85207 Phone Numbers Business: Cellular: Particulars Occupation: EMT FIREFIGHTER Employer: CITY OF CHANDLER FD STATION 11 Height: 5'05 Weight: 140 lbs. Eye color: GREEN Hair color: BLONDE OR STRAWBERRY Hair style: Dreadlocks Master Name Index Reference Name: Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: MESA , Arizona 85207 Phone numbers For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 6 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Business: Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 22-29 Years 9. Contact # 3 - (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: QUEEN CREEK , Arizona 85142 Phone Numbers Business: Cellular: Particulars Occupation: FIRE ENGINEER Employer: CITH OF CHANDLER FD STATION 11 Height: 6'02 Weight: 150 lbs. Eye color: BROWN Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: QUEEN CREEK , Arizona 85142 Phone numbers Business: Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 10. Contact # 4 - (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: MARICOPA , Arizona 85238 For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 7 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Phone Numbers Business: Cellular: Particulars Place of birth: Arizona Occupation: FIREFIGHTER Employer: CITY OF CHANDLER FD STATION 11 Citizenship: United States Ethnicity: White Language(s) spoken: English Height: 5'05 Weight: 160 lbs. Eye color: HAZEL Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: Municipality: MARICOPA , Arizona 85238 Phone numbers Business: Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 11. Contact # 5 - , LESLIE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Municipality: Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , LESLIE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Municipality: Phone numbers Cellular: For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 8 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Linkage factors Age range : 50-64 Years 12. Contact # 6 - , ANNE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Address: Municipality: Phone Numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : Unknown 13. Contact # 7 - , APRIL (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: SANDY , Utah 84094 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Master Name Index Reference Name: , APRIL Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: SANDY , Utah 84094 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 14. Contact # 8 - , ANGELINE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 9 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Date of birth: Address: Municipality: SYRACUSE , Utah 84075 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Master Name Index Reference Name: , ANGELINE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: SYRACUSE , Utah 84075 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Nonresident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 15. Contact # 9 - , SHERRY (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: Unknown , Arizona Phone Numbers Business: Particulars Employer: Master Name Index Reference Name: , SHERRY Sex: Female Race: Unknown , Arizona Phone numbers Business: Linkage factors Age range : Unknown 16. Contact # 10 - , DARA (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: Unknown For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 10 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER , Arizona Phone Numbers Business: Particulars Employer: Master Name Index Reference Name: , DARA Sex: Female Race: Unknown , Arizona Phone numbers Business: Linkage factors Age range : Unknown 17. Contact # 11 - , CHRISTOPHER (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 Phone Numbers Business: Particulars Employer: VALLEY OF THE SUN MORTUARY Master Name Index Reference Name: , CHRISTOPHER Sex: Male Race: White Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 Phone numbers Business: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : Unknown 18. Contact # 12 - , SARENA (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 11 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Address: Municipality: QUEEN CREEK , Arizona 85142 Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , SARENA Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: QUEEN CREEK , Arizona County: MARICOPA 85142 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Age range : 30-49 Years 19. Contact # 13 - , NICOLE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: R24 Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , NICOLE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: R24 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 20. Contact # 14 - , CHRISTINA (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 12 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: T22 Phone Numbers Home: Cellular: Particulars Height: 5'06 Weight: 134 lbs. Eye color: GREEN Hair color: BROWN Additional remarks: NO WORK Master Name Index Reference Name: , CHRISTINA Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 17 Grid: T22 Phone numbers Home: Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 21. Contact # 15 - , KAY (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: LAKE CHARLES , Louisiana 70607 Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , KAY Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: LAKE CHARLES , Louisiana 70607 For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 13 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Age range : Unknown 22. Contact # 16 - , NANCY (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , NANCY Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: MESA , Arizona 85205 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Age range : 50-64 Years 23. Contact # 17 - , SHARIE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: WEST BRIDGEWATER , Massachusetts Phone Numbers Cellular: Master Name Index Reference Name: , SHARIE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: WEST BRIDGEWATER , Massachusetts Phone numbers For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 14 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Cellular: Linkage factors Age range : 50-64 Years 24. Contact # 18 - , RICHARD JASON (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85225 District: 3 Beat: 7 Grid: C14 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Ethnicity: White Language(s) spoken: English Height: 5'09 Weight: 240 lbs. Eye color: BLUE Hair color: BALD (For III Only) Master Name Index Reference Name: , RICHARD JASON Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85225 District: 3 Beat: 7 Grid: C14 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 50-64 Years 25. Contact # 19 - , NIKKI (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85224 District: 3 Beat: 7 Grid: C14 For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 15 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Ethnicity: White Height: 5'07 Weight: 130 lbs. Eye color: GREEN Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: , NIKKI Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85224 District: 3 Beat: 7 Grid: C14 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 30-49 Years 26. Contact # 20 - , DEBBIE (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: HIGHLAND , Utah 84003 Phone Numbers Home: Master Name Index Reference Name: , DEBBIE Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: HIGHLAND , Utah 84003 Phone numbers Home: Linkage factors Age range : 30-49 Years For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 16 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER 27. Contact # 21 - , GABRIEL (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: GILBERT , Arizona 85298 Phone Numbers Home: Master Name Index Reference Name: , GABRIEL Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: Municipality: GILBERT , Arizona 85298 Phone numbers Home: Linkage factors Age range : 30-49 Years 28. Juvenile - Involved # 1 - VALLOW, JOSHUA JAXSON (Case Specific Information) Sex: Male Race: White Date of birth: Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Particulars Occupation: STUDENT Employer: Citizenship: United States Ethnicity: White Language(s) spoken: English Height: 4'03 Weight: 70 lbs. Eye color: BROWN Hair color: BROWN Master Name Index Reference Name: VALLOW, JOSHUA JAXSON Sex: Male Race: White For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 17 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Date of birth: Ethnicity: Not Hispanic or Latino Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona 85249 District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 6-8 Years 29. Juvenile - Witness # 2 - RYAN, TYLEE ASHLYN (Case Specific Information) Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Phone Numbers Cellular: Particulars Height: 5'00 Weight: 160 lbs. Eye color: BLUE Hair color: BLONDE OR STRAWBERRY Master Name Index Reference Name: Sex: Female Race: White Date of birth: Address: 5531 S FOUR PEAKS PL Municipality: CHANDLER , Arizona District: 6 Beat: 18 Grid: S22 Phone numbers Cellular: Linkage factors Resident status : Resident of Chandler Age range : 16-17 Years Related Vehicle(s) 1. Involved # 1 - (Case Specific Information) License number: For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 18 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER State of issue: Colorado VIN #: License type: Regular Passenger Year of issue: 2019 Vehicle type: AUTOMOBILE Make and model: Kia Motors Corp. Sorrento Style: 4-DOOR AUTOMOBILE Year: 2018 Color: Red Master Vehicle Index Reference License number: State of issue: Colorado License type: Regular Passenger Year of issue: 2019 Owner Information Owner type: PERSON Owner role: Involved For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 19 of 1108 CHANDLER POLICE DEPARTMENT GENERAL OCCURRENCE HARDCOPY GO-NUM# CH 2019-83744 CLOSED - Complaint Issued 0999-0 1ST DEGREE MURDER Narrative Text Type Homicide Summary Author 2187 - JESUS BOGGS #S22 (Retired) Related Date Aug-01-2019 10:12 On 07/11/2019 at 0836 hours Patrol responded to a shooting call at 5531 S. Four Peaks Pl. An altercation ensued as a result of a domestic disturbance. One subject died as a result of the shooting. The decedent went to the listed address to pick up his 7 year old son and take him to school. An argument ensued between him and his estranged wife. In an effort to defend her mother, a female juvenile tried to fend off the decedent with a baseball bat. The decedent took the bat from the juvenile and began swinging it. The shooter (decedent's brother in law) intervened and was struck with the bat on the back of his head. The shooter then went into a bedroom and retrieved a handgun. He confronted the decedent and demanded that he leave. Armed with the bat, the decedent moved aggressively towards the shooter, at which time the shooter fired at least twice in what he described as "self-defense." The shooter was released after his interview and this case will be reviewed by the MCAO. The case agent is Det. N. Moffat #493. The case # is 2019-83744 Case Status: Pending F/U by Det. Moffat For: 4678 Printed On: Sep-22-2021 (Wed.) Page 20 of 1108