jcitytimes.com 'He Listens to No One': How the Solomon Administration Came Apart During a Financial Crisis Aaron Morrill 22–27 minutes When Jersey City’s new mayor, James Solomon, nominated Sarah Levine to be the city’s top lawyer in January, his praise was effusive. “Sarah’s combination of legal excellence, public service, and deep roots in Jersey City makes her the ideal person to lead our Law Department,” he said in a press release. As a Yale-trained lawyer with a “track record of taking on complex cases and winning,” she would be “a tireless advocate for Jersey City residents.” In early October, the administration announced that Levine had resigned after just nine months on the job. Two days later, it announced that three more top administration officials had resigned — Finance Director Bill Viqueira, Digital Director Megan Malloy, and Deputy Mayor for Housing and Economic Development Keshav Poddar. The Jersey City Times spoke with seven current and former Jersey City government employees with firsthand knowledge of Solomon’s young administration. Fearing retaliation, all asked to remain anonymous. To protect their anonymity, all will be referred to as “staffers.” In lengthy interviews, they described an administration operating without clearly defined priorities or strategic goals. They spoke of a mayor uninterested in the advice of senior staff and consumed with massaging his public image. Despite supporting Solomon’s stated policy positions, they had all come to question whether he had the managerial skills for the job. Solomon defended his leadership in an hourlong interview. He likened the changes in high-level staff to turnover in the administration of New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani , calling it a “natural process by which an administration settles in and finds its right team.” While leaving many of the criticisms levied against him unaddressed, he touted his successes in the midst of a budget crisis. “Crime is down 25% in the city,” Solomon said. “We have doubled our summer jobs program. We avoided catastrophic layoffs. We cut $60 million [from the budget]. We canceled programs left and right that weren’t essential ... What I would say is I have really high expectations for staff, and I have higher expectations for myself. ” Early Days Like Levine, Viqueira, Malloy and Poddar were highly credentialed and brought a wealth of experience. Poddar , a Yale law graduate, had worked on the National Security Council in the Biden administration, for then- Vice President Kamala Harris, and for former New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal. Viqueira had served as the chief financial officer and treasurer of NJ Transit, overseeing $5 billion in operating and capital budgets and more than 500 employees. Malloy had worked for former President Barack Obama, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, and former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder. Along with Levine, the three had the kind of resumes that rarely crossed the desk of Jersey City’s HR department. Solomon’s high-powered team of managers came to their jobs imbued with enthusiasm. “I was excited about him being a progressive mayor at a time when progressive mayors are exciting and in the zeitgeist ... especially the affordable housing piece,” explained one. Said another, wistfully, “He is someone I believed in.” Despite that enthusiasm, it quickly became clear that much of Solomon’s progressive agenda would take a back seat to balancing the city’s budget. On Feb. 4, Solomon announced that Jersey City was facing a $255 million deficit left by his predecessor, Steven Fulop. In an “astonishing act of fiscal irresponsibility” to bolster his gubernatorial ambitions, Fulop had created a financial “house of cards built on tricks and gimmicks,” Solomon said. To close the budget hole, the City Council ultimately approved an unprecedented 15% tax increase. None of those who spoke with JCT disputed that Solomon inherited a financial and operational mess, or doubted Fulop’s responsibility for it. “When we got there, the entire government apparatus was decrepit and broken,” one staffer said, adding, “I have empathy for Jersey City residents for having a [former] mayor who trashed the city’s finances.” No one questioned the $255 million figure, either. The ‘Smartest Guy in the Room ’ As the administration struggled to plug the budget hole and plot a path forward, Solomon’s managerial inexperience quickly became a liability, the staffers said. In meetings, he showed little interest in his senior lieutenants’ views. “The mayor would gather together a group of us and ignore us,” one staffer said. Solomon’s common response to advice, another staffer said, was “thanks, I’ll think about it.” More often than not, with no explanation, Solomon would overrule a senior official’s recommendations. “He listens to no one,” lamented one staffer. “He makes it very clear that he thinks he’s the smartest guy in the room,” said another. A controversial proposal to spend $1.2 million to buy a plot of land at 128 Glenwood Ave. for a community garden was a case in point. Over the unanimous objections of his staff, Solomon chose to move ahead with the plan, reasoning that it would be good politics to ingratiate himself with the community. One staffer remembered angrily thinking: “You promised these people you’re going to buy them a park? If they want the park, let them buy their own f- – – ing park.” Moreover, the garden, said another disillusioned staffer, had “absolutely nothing to do with any of [Solomon’s] original stated priorities.” Ultimately, the proposal died in the City Council The July layoffs of 31 provisional civil servants were another example, staffers said. Without soliciting input from the affected department heads, Solomon, Chief of Staff Laura Bustamante, and Business Administrator Ruby Choi “sat in front of a computer screen and picked names off of the spreadsheet,” a staffer said. One of the laid-off civil servants handled Open Public Records Act requests. The firing substantially increased an already existing backlog, they said. Ultimately, 11 of the employees were rehired. Solomon also had an intimidating physicality about him, said a staffer. “He would get visibly upset” when people offered ideas or opinions, sometimes snapping or cutting them off in front of colleagues, adding, “He made it very clear to everybody what he was thinking.” Some younger City Hall employees were reduced to tears after interactions with the mayor. Some staffers opined that the pressure of running a city during a financial crisis was simply too much for Solomon. “We were in crisis mode for a while. Pretty much all through June, July, into August,” said one. “He had some mannerisms that showed, I think, a level of anxiety, you know, weight — playing with his hands or toys. We kind of joked about [him] chewing on his fist. There were things that suggest he was feeling the stress.” Solomon’s moods dictated if and when communication was possible. “I do recall many times hearing things like, ‘Well, today’s not the day to talk to the mayor because he’s in a bad mood,’” a staffer said. Some of the pressure appeared to be self-created. Despite statements during the campaign that he would not run for governor, one staffer said the goal was “very much top of mind” for him. That, in turn, increased the pressure to raise money. Several staffers suggested that Solomon’s lack of social skills contributed to the administration’s dysfunction. One staffer called him an “enthusiastic communicator to the public” but less adept at one-on-one interactions. “He has a fear of confrontation,” said one. Another bemoaned his unwillingness to give feedback, saying: “How do you, as a manager, as a leader ... not approach your team and have a conversation, honest conversation, about what you think is going well or not, well before you make these decisions. It’s incompetent; it’s reckless.” Another staffer concluded, “He doesn’t know his people. He’s transactional.” It quickly became apparent that face time with Solomon would be far more limited than his staff expected. Outside scheduled meetings, Bustamante controlled access to the mayor. When pressed for time, knocking on Solomon’s door to get a quick decision or feedback was not an option. Instead, staffers were expected to follow numerous standard operating procedures governing a wide range of activities, including communications with Solomon. One staffer recalled emailing an important report to Solomon for inclusion in his daily briefing book. Days later, Director of Operations Kaitlyn Gavin responded that the staffer had not followed the process outlined on a specific date, so the report was neither included in the briefing book nor reviewed by the mayor. Should a refresher on the process be needed, she wrote, “I would be happy to provide it to you.” Staffers complained of spending precious time on what they considered ill-conceived mayoral requests. One was Solomon’s demand that each department head create three budgets: “gold, silver and bronze.” Given the city’s limited financial resources, “it was a complete waste of time,” one staffer said. “If you go to a larger department, and you start asking people for a wish list, you are creating an extraordinary amount of work,” said another. Said one: “Sometimes we would go down a whole path ... just to give him something ... and then he would decide not to move forward with it. So we would have wasted all this time.” Staffers also chafed at Solomon’s willingness to employ some of the tricks he had accused Fulop of using. He had complained about Fulop’s use of one-time revenue boosters, such as land sales, to fund the budget. But with pressure to increase revenues under his own watch, and over the objection of his staff, Solomon warmed to the practice. He enlisted state Sen. Raj Mukherji to introduce bills allowing the city to divert proceeds from its Open Space Trust Fund and a car-rental tax to fund operating expenses. Gov. Mikie Sherrill vetoed the two bills in September. The Business Administrator Staffers also questioned the hiring of Business Administrator Ruby Choi. At $280,000, Choi, who holds degrees in political science and international affairs, is the administration’s highest-paid member. She had come to the job from the New York City Office of Technology and Innovation, where she focused on IT. According to staffers, she had little experience relevant to running a city, let alone one of Jersey City’s size and complexity. “I’d be hard-pressed for anybody to tell me why Solomon thought she was a reasonable candidate to perform this job,” one said. Another complained that, as the rest of the team struggled with the budget crisis, Choi took a three-week vacation before starting the job. Problems emerged quickly. Staffers complained that Choi began “stepping on others’ toes,” circumventing senior staff and interceding in matters under their purview. Council members grew frustrated when, at one budget hearing, she could not answer basic questions about Department of Health and Human Services cuts. “She doesn’t understand the city,” one staffer said. Another said, “A lot of people were frustrated with Ruby.” Choi sent “endless requests to produce work product that served no meaningful purpose,” a third staffer said. Staffers were also frustrated by Bustamante. A well-known figure in Jersey City, Bustamante worked as Solomon’s chief of staff when he was Ward E councilman. She went on to become deputy state director for U.S. Sen. Andy Kim. While staffers considered Bustamante smart, one said she was “learning on the job rather than coming to the job with a lot of experience running an organization.” Despite the pair’s inexperience, Solomon had increasingly relied on Choi and Bustamante, sidelining his other senior staffers, they said. Their inexperience was on full display, staffers said, when Solomon decided to fire Communications Director Nathaniel Styer. The Unravelling On the morning of Sept. 22, Solomon’s department heads gathered for a meeting. “We’re sitting there for about 20 minutes, and everybody’s like, ‘What the hell’s going on?’ Everybody’s phone goes off at the same time,” one staffer said. “It’s Nathaniel, I’ve been fired,” the staffer remembers reading. A short time later, Solomon explained that in terminating Styer, he wanted to “reset” communications and “maintain certain baseline standards at all times.” A staffer remembers thinking, “There are no standards here at all.” Solomon said Styer had failed to communicate to the public what “the four pillars of the administration” were. “We all looked at each other, and, pardon my language, said, ‘what the f- – – are the four pillars?’” said a staffer. Jersey City Mayor James Solomon, with, from left, Chief of Staff Laura Bustamante, Deputy Mayor for Housing and Economic Development Keshav Poddar, and Communications Director Nathaniel Styer, holds a press conference after Solomon’s inauguration at the Gothic Lounge at New Jersey City University on Thursday, Jan. 15, 2026. (Reena Rose Sibayan | For Jersey City Times) Staffers were infuriated at how Styer had been treated and questioned Bustamante’s involvement. “If you are going to terminate people, your director of HR is the person that does that, maybe the BA on the side, but the chief of staff?” said one. “It was such a mess. It was just like when they fired those 31 people. These people don’t know what they’re doing.” Styer’s termination wasn’t the only example of questionable HR practices. In a sharply worded letter a week after her resignation, Levine wrote that the administration had locked her out of her office and computer, though she had offered to work “paid or unpaid ... to ensure continuity of legal representation and avoid disruption to the Law Department’s operations.” The lockout had caused “an existential threat to [her] ethical obligations as an attorney and [her] official responsibilities as the city’s attorney,” she said. Chasing Clicks While the staffers uniformly held Styer in high regard, Solomon did not share their view. He blamed Styer for negative coverage in the press and on social media, they said. Solomon was “obsessed,” the staffers agreed, with a torrent of critical posts on the Facebook page known as The Hudson County Chronicles , owned by Jersey City resident Bruce Alston. “There were multiple instances where we explicitly discussed Chronicler posts in senior team meetings,” recalled one staffer. “I remember Nathaniel many, many times venting to me about his frustration with being tasked with managing the narrative and getting ahead of unfavorable reporting by Bruce. And Nathaniel would essentially say: ‘How do you get your arms around someone who’s totally unscrupulous, who doesn’t follow the normal rules of the road in journalistic ethics? There’s no way that, using the tools in my profession, that’s something I’m capable of doing.’” As Solomon’s frustration with Alston grew, staffers saw him push Styer to respond more forcefully, sometimes with messaging unsupported by facts. “We were in a meeting, and the mayor was pushing about comms, and Nathaniel said, ‘I can only communicate what is true,’” recalled one staffer. “He was placed in an impossible situation,” said a staffer of Styer. “The communications out of this administration started with James and nobody but James. Nathaniel, as best I could tell, was a loyal soldier who tried to do, as best he could, what the mayor wanted.” Bruce Alston did not respond to emails requesting comment. If Solomon hoped to forget Bruce Alston, he couldn’t stop talking about Fulop, even as it became clear that residents viewed Solomon as at least partly to blame for the deficit because of his City Council tenure. “It’s like, you don’t even see your own culpability in any of this after being on council for eight years?” said one staffer. The administration’s presentations on the deficit were also a problem. One staffer thought Solomon spent too much time in long presentations on the minutiae. For another, it was the substance, which they described as confusing. “It was really confusing how we were talking about the structural deficit versus the one-time debt.” Solomon, they said, was uninterested in hearing their feedback. All of the staffers JCT spoke to said Solomon spent too much time on communications. “I think an inordinate amount of time of senior leadership meetings that I was in was spent focusing on communications rather than on substance or operations,” said one. A staffer said that Solomon openly expressed the desire to emulate New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. “I think there was kind of an obsessiveness about it,” they said. Unbeknownst to some, Styer’s fate and those of other senior staffers may have been sealed five days before his termination, at a secret “leadership retreat” in Manhattan. Coordinated by Andrea Batista of the consulting firm HR&A, and attended by Solomon, Choi, Bustamante, and Gavin, the meeting aimed to establish “concrete, owned commitments to drive culture change and execute the Mayor’s priorities for the remainder of the year,” according to the agenda. The staffers weren’t told of the meeting, but word of it got out nonetheless. The agenda for the meeting was later leaked to The Hudson County Chronicles. One of the agenda items, “staffing discussion,” asked: “Are there specific staffing or personnel situations that need a decision? Identify them by name if needed, but treat any termination, demotion, or disciplinary decision as something to finalize afterward, privately, and in line with HR process — not something to decide in this room in the moment.” Staffers had previously watched disapprovingly as Solomon suspended mayoral aide and former Solomon campaign manager Stuart Thomas over remarks Thomas made that some considered insensitive. One staffer described everyone’s thinking following Styer’s termination: “They’ re all sitting there like, ‘Oh, sh–, am I next?’” Within weeks of Styer’s termination, Levine, Poddar, Viqueira and Malloy were gone. The mayor said Poddar, Viqueira and Malloy were leaving as part of a “restructuring.” Solomon Responds During his interview, Solomon seemed unperturbed by the criticism. Without admitting any shortcomings as a manager, he said his skills could improve. “I will be actively seeking out professional development for the entire time that I am mayor to become better,” he said, noting that he is being coached through the Bloomberg Harvard City Leadership Initiative He credited himself with limiting the 2026 tax increase to 15%. “Voices in City Hall and at the state level were pushing for tax increases between 25% and 30%,” he said. “And when we say the state — these are bureaucrats, to be clear. “To give you kind of a sense of the challenge here ... when we first met and understood the scope of the budget ... one of the things Laura (Bustamante) said to me was ... no city has ever gotten roughly more than $70 million. And she’s like, so realistically, we should be thinking about getting $70 million to $60 million from the state. And I was just like, but if we only get $60 million to $70 million from the state, we’re screwed.” Despite being a self-described “anti-establishment politician,” he was able to cajole Trenton into giving Jersey City $120 million in state loans and aid, he said. Regarding the senior staff departures, he only hinted at friction. The budget crisis involved “stress” and “tough conversations,” he said. “Not that everything was perfect, but that I stand behind ultimately the outcome in the process by which we drove this forward.” Solomon readily admitted to overruling his senior staff on whether to buy land for a community garden at 128 Glenwood Ave. “It was my decision because we were able to acquire open space ... [for a] neighborhood that desperately needs open space,” he said. The allegation that Solomon, Choi, and Bustamante fired the 31 provisional employees without consultation with department heads was false. Ultimately, 11 of the 31 were rehired. Also untrue was the claim that he wanted to end up in the governor’s mansion, he said. “Let me just say, it’s 1,000% false ... I have literally never once thought and had any interest in running for governor, because I know the extraordinary sacrifices that would mean for Gabby and for my kids.” Solomon did not directly address the claim that he was “obsessed” with The Hudson County Chronicles, saying his “focus is delivering for residents.” As to whether Solomon spends too much time on communications and social media, Bustamante, who sat in on the interview, said: “We’re not shy about it ... the mayor is constantly communicating with residents.” On why the five senior staffers left, he offered little more, saying he “just can’t get into the deeper personnel matters.” He said no one complained about their performance. “I am grateful for the service of each of those folks,” Solomon said. “They all worked extraordinarily hard for the city in advancing ... [it] forward.” Pressed on his comparison of the staff departures in the Mamdani administration to those in his own, Solomon disputed the suggestion that those leaving Mamdani’s office had largely been holdovers from the Adams administration. He said he would provide JCT with proof to back up his claim, but he didn’t. According to published reports, none of Mamdani’s own appointees have resigned or been fired since the inauguration. Epilogue Several of the staffers expressed deep concern about Solomon’s ability to navigate Jersey City’s future challenges, including the $50 million-plus budget deficit looming in 2027. Referring to New Jersey’s Department of Community Affairs, which approved Jersey City’s $105 million loan- bailout in June, a staffer opined: “DCA needs to start taking a much stronger role in oversight, over decisions, daily decisions being made by this administration —hiring, firings, salaries, contracts, everything that they would normally do ... The DCA is gonna need to step it up.” Yet there are still small reserves of goodwill toward the mayor among the staffers. One expressed ambivalence about airing the Solomon administration’s dirty laundry, saying, “I have no desire to subvert the ability for this administration to succeed.” Said another, “He wants to do the right thing and is willing to work really hard.” All agreed that Solomon was smart and well-informed. “He has a freakish mind for minute policy details,” said one. In a recent “ Ask the Mayor ” YouTube segment, Solomon was asked to explain the departures of his senior staff. Pressed by the host, David Cruz, he said, “The team didn’t gel.” But the staffers who spoke with JCT said nothing could have been further from the truth. In interviews, they described a tightly-knit group united by mutual admiration and a desire to help Jersey City. Their colleagues were, they said, “the best” and “rock stars.” Said one staffer: “We all have a lot of respect for each other. ... These are friends of mine. I respect them as professionals.”