© 2025 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. After decades of intensive expansion and mining, the iron ore deposits that fed China’s industrial boom are beginning to show their years. Iron content is degrading and impurities increasing, challenging the pricing mechanism on which trade in this integral commodity depends. As iron ore specifications fall below the benchmarks against which they price, what new tools are required to navigate the next phase? One mainstay Australian product, Rio Tinto’s flagship Pilbara Blend Fines (PBF), sustained quality close to the 62pc Fe index through strategic blending from multiple mines. But at a cost — maintaining a consistent blend from increasingly degraded ore bodies meant a reduction in volume. This led to a dramatic plunge in the availability of spot PBF that helps determine index prices ( see chart ). To bolster availability, Rio Tinto lowered the typical grade of the blend for July loadings onwards. The first cargo of PBF with a new specification of 60.8pc Fe was sold on the spot market on 13 May. The grade change should increase PBF volumes. But given the scale of PBF production and the role that it plays as a base-load product, it will also shift the centre of gravity of the iron ore market. The change in blend crystalises the gulf between the products trading and the indexes that they price against. Not only do all mainstream Australian fines now sit below index specification, but the “anchor” around which products relativities sit has moved. Put simply, the 62pc benchmark now represents a specification that no longer exists. As a result, the current pricing mechanism faces its biggest change since it came into being. Since 2010, the index-based pricing mechanism centred around 62pc Fe iron ore has relied on a steady volume of consistent products — particularly Australian medium- grade fines — to establish transparent pricing. This grade became a benchmark because indexes with this specification were underpinned by a liquid and transparent spot market comprising relatively fungible products from a range of suppliers. Such liquidity and consistency were key to the health and integrity of the pricing mechanism, which has functioned smoothly in recent years, with very little controversy. Derivatives volumes have soared, and the introduction of “basket pricing” using a range of indexes introduced more competition and diversity in pricing options. During the evolution of this system, the ageing and gradual degradation of the products sustaining it received little attention. Yet the grades feeding into the benchmark price have been on a steady downtrend that accelerated last year. BHP’s Newman Fines once contained 63pc iron, but its typical specification is now below 62pc Fe. MAC Fines and Jimblebar Fines — the other two medium-grade BHP products regularly seen in the spot market — have also drifted below 61pc Fe ( see chart ). Brazilian mines have also faced grade decline. Insight Paper | May 2025 Iron ore pricing mechanisms: The grades they are a changin’ 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 PBF NHGF MACF JMBF BRBF 2025 annualised based on April YTD Spot transactions recorded by Argus 59 60 61 62 63 Sep-17 Oct-18 Nov-19 Dec-20 Jan-22 Feb-23 Mar-24 Apr-25 PBF* NHGF MACF JMBF Typical iron content falling below 62pc % Insight Paper | Iron ore pricing mechanisms 2 This document has been prepared by the Argus Media group (referred to herein as “Argus”) for informational purposes only and has not been prepared for any particular purpose. The information or opinions contained in this document are provided on an “as is” basis and should not be construed as legal, tax, accounting or investment advice or the rendering of legal, consulting, or other professional services of any kind. To the maximum extent permitted by law, neither Argus nor its directors, shareholders, personnel or advisers makes any representations or warranties as to the accuracy or complete- ness of this document. Argus offers no implied warranty, representation or confirmation of merchantability or fitness for any particular purpose and accepts no responsibility what - soever for any damages arising from the use of or reliance on the information contained in or omitted from this document and any related materials (such as slides, handouts, other presentation documents and recordings and any other materials or information distributed at a presentation at which this document is displayed or in connection with this document) (whether arising by breach of contract, tort (including the tort of negligence), breach of statutory duty, or otherwise). No rights or remedies are conferred upon the recipients of this document or any other person. Data and information contained in the document come from a variety of sources, some of which are third parties outside Argus’ control and some of which may not have been verified. Any analysis and opinions, data, projections and forecasts provided may be based on assumptions that are not correct or which change, being dependent upon fundamentals and other factors and events subject to change and uncertainty; future results or values could be materially different from any forecast or estimates described in the document. Copyright notice: Copyright © 2025 Argus Media group. All rights reserved. All intellectual property rights in this document and the information herein are the exclusive property of Argus and/or its licensors and may only be used under licence from Argus. Without limiting the foregoing, you will not copy or reproduce any part of its contents (including, but not limited to, single prices or any other individual items of data) in any form or for any purpose whatsoever without the prior written consent of Argus. Trademark notice: ARGUS, the ARGUS logo, Argus publication titles, the tagline “illuminating the markets®”, and Argus index names are trademarks of Argus Media Limited. For addi- tional information, including details of our other trademarks, visit argusmedia.com/trademarks. argusmedia.com Pricing troubles Grade decline had already been impacting the efficiency of the market pricing mechanism. Products formerly trading at parity to the 62pc Fe index are subject to increasingly wide differentials, reintroducing the need for regular adjustments and adding basis risk when hedging using futures. And because indexes reference a theoretical specification higher than the ores it was originally meant to represent, all contributing grades must now be quality-adjusted. Establishing these differentials becomes increasingly difficult when the baseline against which they are set has moved. Readjusting to the new reality will be complicated, but worthwhile. The iron ore pricing ecosystem is highly evolved and financialised. Its development has been a success story that has helped manage the heightened volatility created by China’s rapid expansion in steelmaking. At the heart of this ecosystem is a physical market — miners, traders and mills buying and selling a tangible commodity used to produce tangible products. Surrounding this core are trading platforms and price reporting agencies (PRAs), which amalgamate on and off-screen data provided by physical participants to construct indexes that raise market efficiency. The outer layer is the “paper” community — banks, brokers and exchanges providing price risk management services to the physical community and a growing number of non-physical actors. Each adds value, but all ultimately service the physical market. Financial futures may be multiples of the physical market, but must finally reconcile with the underlying commodity through either physical delivery or settlement against a physical index. As the physical market underpinning this system changes, the outer layers of the ecosystem will probably eventually need to follow. New realities, new options From 2 June, Argus will begin publishing an assessment for 61pc Fe iron ore fines with higher impurities to align with typical specifications of the most frequently traded medium grade fines products in the spot market ( see table ). The closer alignment between index and product specifications will support tighter quality normalisations, improve usability in floating price agreements, and help bridge the gap between existing benchmarks and the current market. This additional index will be published alongside the existing ICX 62pc Fe iron ore index using both the same methodology and underlying spot market data. Despite the ongoing changes, 62pc references remain embedded — not least in long-term contracts. Both physical index-linked contracts and futures are current or historical agreements based on a past understanding of a future reality. Rather than shift that basis of any existing contracts, Argus will provide new options to reflect the new physical reality and support the ongoing evolution of the iron ore pricing system. 60 61 62 63 Sep-17 Nov-19 May-21 Jul-22 Jun-23 Apr-24 Apr-25 ICX 62 ICX 61 PBF* NHGF MACF Iron 3.6 3.8 4.0 4.2 4.4 4.6 4.8 Sep-17 Nov-19 May-21 Jul-22 Jun-23 Apr-24 Apr-25 ICX 62 ICX 61 PBF* NHGF MACF Silica 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 Nov-17 Nov-19 Jun-21 Jul-22 Jun-23 May-24 Apr-25 ICX 62 ICX 61 PBF* NHGF MACF Alumina ICX 61pc realigns index specification with most liquid spot products % Argus 61pc/62pc fines, cfr Qingdao (ICX™) specifications % dry basis Iron Silica Alumina Phosphorus Sulphur Moisture ICX 62% Fe 62% 3.75% 2.25% 0.10% 0.02% 8% ICX 61% Fe 61% 4.30% 2.50% 0.10% 0.02% 8%